|
Can coloured filters help reading? Yes they can
Olive Meares first suggested in New Zealand that
children with visual reading difficulties might see more easily through
coloured filters. This was taken up commercially in the USA and UK.
Each child is usually individually prescribed a special colour; so the
glasses tend to cost a lot! However the visual magnocellular system is
mainly influenced by only yellow and blue light; so only these two
colours should make much difference. We have confirmed that indeed only
deep yellow or blue glasses are really useful.
We’ve shown that about one third of children with visual reading
problems can be helped greatly by cheap yellow, ‘negative blue’,
filters. Yellow cuts out the blue end of the spectrum; and thus
bolsters the visual magnocellular system that controls the focus and
movements of the eyes. So Nicky Ray and Sue Fowler have just finished a
randomised controlled trial (RCT) in which they studied dyslexic
children who benefited from wearing deep yellow glasses when reading.
They
assessed their visual magnocellular performance by testing contrast,
motion sensitivity and eye control. They compared these with their
reading ability before and 3 months after they had been randomly
allocated either yellow glasses or a 'placebo' treatment- a card with a
window cut in it, so that only one line at a time could be seen. This
was intended to reduce distraction from neighbouring lines, and it has
been found to help some dyslexic children a bit.
The children who received the yellow glasses did exceptionally well
compared with the placebo. Their contrast, motion sensitivity and eye
control improved greatly, so that in just the 3 months their reading
increased by 8 1/2 ms, compared with the placebo group who improved by
only 3 months. This difference was highly unlikely to have been just
due to chance (P < 0.05). The improvements probably occurred because
the yellow glasses boosted the performance of their visual
magnocellular system.
Another
third of children are helped by looking through deep blue
filters. In their randomised control trial Nicky and Sue found
that the children who chose blue improved their reading even more than
the yellows - by nine months in the 3 months, 6 months faster than
those given the placebo. We believe the blue filters work
by boosting the eyes' input to the hypothalamus which controls our
night/day responses, our 'diurnal' rhythms. These children often have
disturbed sleep patterns and they often suffer from headaches.
Then the blue filters not only help their reading but their sleep and
headaches too!
|