|
The Dyslexia
'Myth' -Dispatches, TV Channel 4, 8.9.05.
I suppose TV has
to be provocative....but Prof. Julian Elliot claiming that dyslexia
does not exist could be very damaging; especially when the rest of the
programme showed some of the genetic and neurological evidence that it
does exist, and is common! Elliot ignored this.
The programme was
very unbalanced, focussing only on old research that showed that many
dyslexics have problems with sorting out the sounds of letters,
phonics, without asking why they have those difficulties. They featured
a phonics' teaching system that requires 28 expensive hours of 1:1
teaching!
They mistakenly
ruled out visual causes, ignoring over 500 scientific publications in
the last 10 years that show the importance of visual factors in
dyslexia, together with their contribution to the phonological problems
that the programme featured.
Worse they
ignored the dramatic reading progress that many children can achieve
simply by improving their visual reading skills using cheap simple
means such as coloured filters, vergence exercises or temporary
occlusion of one eye.
|